Nest offerings sell out quickly.
Join waitlist

Short-term vs. Long-term Investing: Weighing the Pros and Cons to Maximize Returns

Published on
January 24, 2023
Written by
Patrick Duncan
Read time
5 mins

The world of real estate investing offers a plethora of options, with short-term and long-term rental properties being two of the most popular choices. Each investment strategy comes with its unique set of benefits and challenges, and the decision to pursue one or the other depends on an investor's financial goals, risk tolerance, and time commitment. In this blog post, we will explore the key differences between short-term and long-term rental investing, discussing the pros and cons of each to help you make an informed decision for your investment portfolio.

Short-term Rental Investing

Short-term rental properties, also known as vacation rentals, are typically rented out for a few days to several weeks at a time. They cater to travelers and vacationers seeking a comfortable and unique lodging experience, and their popularity has grown significantly with the rise of platforms like Airbnb and Vrbo.

Pros of Short-term Rental Investing

Higher Rental Income: Short-term rentals tend to generate higher rental income per night compared to long-term rentals. This can result in a greater return on investment, especially in high-demand tourist destinations. On average, short-term rentals generate 193% higher rental revenue when comparing AirDNA short-term rental data to long-term rental data from Zillow.

Flexibility of Personal Use: Investors can use their short-term rental properties for personal vacations or visits when they are not rented out, enjoying a cost-effective vacation home.

Dynamic Pricing: Short-term rental investors have the flexibility to adjust their pricing based on market demand, seasonality, and special events. This can help maximize rental income during peak periods and minimize vacancies during slower times.

Lower Risk of Long-term Tenant Issues: Since guests typically stay for shorter periods, short-term rental investors are less likely to encounter long-term tenant-related problems, such as non-payment of rent or property damage.

Cons of Short-term Rental Investing

High Initial Investment: Vacation rental properties are often located in desirable tourist destinations, which can result in higher property prices and a larger initial investment.

Seasonal Demand: Short-term rental properties may experience seasonal fluctuations in demand, leading to inconsistent rental income and potential vacancies during off-peak seasons.

Property Management: Managing a short-term rental property can be time-consuming and labor-intensive due to frequent guest turnover, cleaning, and maintenance. This may necessitate hiring a property management company or dedicating significant personal time to these tasks.

Regulatory Hurdles: Local regulations and laws regarding short-term rentals can vary greatly, and some areas have restrictive policies in place. Investors must be aware of and comply with these regulations to avoid potential fines or legal issues.

Long-term Rental Investing

Long-term rental properties, also known as traditional rentals, are leased out to tenants for extended periods, typically on a yearly basis. These properties cater to individuals and families seeking stable, long-term housing options.

Pros of Long-term Rental Investing

Consistent Cash Flow: Long-term rentals provide a steady stream of monthly rental income, offering investors predictable cash flow and financial stability.

Lower Management Effort: With longer tenant stays and less frequent turnover, managing a long-term rental property generally requires less time and effort compared to a short-term rental.

Appreciation Potential: Like all real estate investments, including short-term rentals, long-term rental properties have the potential to appreciate in value over time, providing investors with the opportunity to build wealth through capital gains.

Tax Benefits: Depending on local tax laws, long-term rental property owners may be able to take advantage of tax deductions related to property management, maintenance, and depreciation.

Cons of Long-term Rental Investing

Lower Rental Income: Long-term rentals typically generate lower monthly rental income compared to short-term rentals, which may result in a slower return on investment.

Tenant Issues: Long-term rental investors may encounter challenges related to tenant management, such as non-payment of rent, property damage, or eviction processes.

Limited Personal Use: Unlike short-term rentals, long-term rental properties are generally not available for personal use, as they are occupied by tenants on a long-term basis.

Less Pricing Flexibility: Long-term rental investors have less flexibility to adjust rental rates based on market conditions or seasonality, as rental agreements are typically set for an extended period.


When it comes to real estate investing, choosing between short-term and long-term rental properties is a crucial decision that depends on your individual goals, preferences, and resources. Short-term rentals offer the potential for higher rental income, flexibility, and dynamic pricing, but they come with challenges such as increased management responsibilities and regulatory hurdles. On the other hand, long-term rentals provide consistent cash flow, lower management demands, and long-term tenant relationships, but may generate lower returns and lack the personal-use flexibility of short-term rentals. By carefully evaluating the pros and cons of each investment strategy, you can select the best option for your portfolio and pave the way to a successful real estate investment journey.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Thanks for joining our newsletter
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.